Fuel Tank Door Cap for Volkswagen Golf 2014-2019 Fuel Filler Flap Cover Clip Type No.5G0809909 White ABS

Just shave off the tabs that lock the actuator and get a new cover. It will sit flush and you can just pull it open with your fingernail, or carefully with the key. This is the cover I got and it fit perfectly - https://a.co/d/01Xo3tIM Hopefully they, or another seller, have it in your color.