Fire & Smoke Society Salt-Free Dilly Licious Seasoning Blend | All Purpose Seasoning | Chicken, Fish, Potatoes, Veggies | Garlic, Onion, Dill | M 3.9 oz

You're doing it wrong. This is what you need. Plain cheap yellow mustard with this: https://a.co/d/0hDpOlf3 Pickle seasoning is dried dill, vinegar powder, onions powder, and garlic powder and maybe some citric acid. You can literally buy these separately to make your own blend or a pre made blend to add to anything.